20 Frozen Pizzas I Tried And Ranked—And the Winner Surprised Me

Frozen pizza is everywhere—from late-night snacks to lazy Sunday dinners. But let’s be honest: some pies hit the spot, while others taste like cardboard with cheese.

So I cooked, sliced, and tasted 20 different frozen pizzas to find out which ones actually deliver. The one that took the crown? Total shocker—and totally delicious.

1. California Pizza Kitchen Thin Crust BBQ Chicken

California Pizza Kitchen’s BBQ Chicken pizza is like a mini culinary adventure. The thin crust supports a savory balance of tangy BBQ sauce and smoky chicken.

However, the onions and cilantro play second fiddle here. It’s a decent pick but lacks the punch to climb higher. It’s a flavorful ride that just falls short of spectacular.

2. Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni

Red Baron brings us a classic pepperoni pizza with a crust that stays crispy yet chewy. The pepperoni is generously portioned, adding a nice spice.

Unfortunately, the sauce is a bit too sweet, overshadowing other flavors. While it delivers nostalgia, it doesn’t quite claim a top spot.

3. Amy’s Roasted Vegetable Pizza

Amy’s offers a garden-fresh experience with their roasted vegetable pizza. Each bite bursts with organic veggies, delighting vegetarians and non-vegetarians alike.

The thin crust is crisp but sometimes overpowers the delicate toppings. A healthful choice that’s tasty, though it doesn’t make the top tier.

4. Totino’s Party Pizza

Remember those late-night snacks in college? Totino’s Party Pizza takes you back with its crispy crust and scattered pepperoni bits.

While it’s a fun nibble, it’s more about nostalgia than culinary excellence. This party pizza is a playful, budget-friendly option with limited appeal.

5. DiGiorno Rising Crust Four Cheese

DiGiorno’s rising crust pizza boasts a cloud-like, pillowy base topped with a quartet of cheeses. It’s a gooey, cheesy delight that satisfies the biggest of appetites.

Though the crust is a showstopper, the cheese blend could use more variety. It’s delightful, ranking comfortably in the middle.

6. Tombstone Original Pepperoni

Tombstone’s Original Pepperoni is a straightforward pizza with a crispy thin crust and even pepperoni spread. The cheese melts perfectly, creating a satisfying bite every time.

Though classic, it lacks innovation or unique flair. A reliable choice, it falls in the mid-rank among peers.

7. Trader Joe’s Organic Cheese & Tomato

Trader Joe’s delivers a rustic, organic taste with their cheese and tomato pizza. The mozzarella is creamy, and the tomatoes taste fresh from the garden.

While charmingly simple, it doesn’t quite stand out among richer competitors. A serene, organic option that pleases but doesn’t thrill.

8. Mama Cozzi’s Take & Bake Thin Crust

Mama Cozzi’s Take & Bake offers a hands-on pizza experience. The thin crust comes alive with mozzarella, pepperoni, and bell pepper toppings.

Great for those who enjoy crafting their perfect bake, but it can lack consistency in flavor. An interactive meal that ranks towards the middle.

9. Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza

Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza is reminiscent of childhood flavors. Its chewy crust and ample pepperoni bring back fond memories of pizza night.

Though comforting, it misses complexity in taste. A hearty, uncomplicated choice that doesn’t quite reach the top tier.

10. 365 Everyday Value Thin Crust Supreme

365 Everyday Value presents a supreme pizza that’s a feast for the eyes. Laden with pepperoni, sausage, and veggies, it promises a full flavor profile.

However, the thin crust struggles to support its topping bounty. An ambitious offering that impresses but doesn’t quite conquer.

11. Freschetta Brick Oven Crust

Freschetta’s Brick Oven Crust pizza is like a trip to an Italian pizzeria. The crust has that perfect brick oven taste, paired with mozzarella and savory herbs.

Yet, the sauce sometimes tips into tangy territory. A solid choice for those who seek authenticity without leaving home.

12. Wild Mike’s Ultimate Pepperoni

Wild Mike’s lives up to its name with Ultimate Pepperoni. Extra pepperoni slices pepper the pizza, delivering a robust and spicy flavor.

The zest in the sauce adds a spicy kick that stands out. It’s a bold choice for those who like their pizzas to pack a punch.

13. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Margherita

Newman’s Own serves up a thin and crispy Margherita. The fresh mozzarella and basil dance on a crispy crust, offering a delicate balance.

While elegant, the simplicity might not satisfy those craving a hearty meal. A refined choice that holds its own with grace.

14. Whole Foods Market Cauliflower Crust

Whole Foods Market transforms pizza with a cauliflower crust. It’s gluten-free but doesn’t sacrifice taste, topped with vibrant tomatoes and basil.

The crust is surprisingly sturdy, yet some might miss traditional dough. A modern twist that stands out for innovation and health.

15. California Pizza Kitchen White Pizza

California Pizza Kitchen’s White Pizza is a creamy dream. The white sauce, spinach, and cheese blend are exquisite on a thin crust.

However, the garlic can be overpowering at times. A delightful option for fans of white pizzas, standing comfortably above its peers.

16. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge Cheese

Screamin’ Sicilian’s Bessie’s Revenge is a cheese lover’s paradise. A thick crust supports a cheese blend that screams flavor in every bite.

It’s decadent, though some might find it overly rich. A standout for cheese enthusiasts who crave a gooey, cheesy indulgence.

17. Target Good & Gather Four Cheese

Target’s Good & Gather Four Cheese is a testament to cheesy goodness. Mozzarella, provolone, parmesan, and asiago create a harmonious blend.

The thin crust complements the cheese but can sometimes be overshadowed. A delightful, cheesy feast that stands out among frozen choices.

18. DiGiorno Croissant Crust Pepperoni

DiGiorno introduces an innovative twist with their croissant crust pepperoni pizza. The flaky crust adds a luxurious texture to each bite.

Pepperoni spices up the creamy layers, though it might be too buttery for some. A creative option that wins points for originality and flavor.

19. Motor City Deep Dish Pizza

Motor City’s Deep Dish Pizza is nothing short of a hearty feast. The thick, airy crust cradles gooey cheese and rich tomato sauce, creating a delightful bite.

It’s indulgent, perhaps too much for light eaters. A top contender for those who love substantial, fulfilling meals.

20. Outsiders Milwaukee-Style Sausage & Pepperoni

Outsiders’ Milwaukee-Style Pizza is a hearty slice of Midwestern delight. Sausage and pepperoni rest atop a buttery crust, offering robust flavors.

The richness is balanced, providing a satisfying meal. Its unique style and hearty toppings earn it a high rank among competitors.