16 Popular Orange Juice Brands, Ranked from Best To Worst

Picture this: You’re craving a refreshing glass of OJ—something bright, tangy, and just-squeezed delicious. Then you grab a carton, pour, and…are met with a bland, watery letdown. Sound familiar? The truth is, not all orange juices deserve a spot in your fridge.

To help you avoid disappointment, we sipped and ranked 16 popular brands—from the truly sun-kissed stars bursting with flavor, to the ones that taste more like watered-down citrus.

Ready to discover your new favorite morning pick-me-up?

1. Simply Orange

A crisp, natural citrus flavor takes center stage with Simply Orange. Its taste is as close as you can get to fresh-squeezed perfection.

Hailing from real oranges and not from concentrate, it delivers pure, unadulterated refreshment. The consistency is smooth, and the aroma is wonderfully zesty.

2. Natalie’s Orchid Island Juice

Natalie’s Orchid Island Juice exudes small-batch charm and ultra-fresh quality. A burst of tropical sunshine flavors this juice with genuine care.

Handcrafted with passion, it steers clear of unnecessary additives. This artisanal offering is a standout for those seeking purity in every sip.

3. Florida’s Natural

Florida’s Natural brings the vibrant taste of sun-drenched oranges right to your glass. Its bold, citrusy punch is a testament to Florida’s rich agricultural heritage.

This juice prides itself on being made from Florida-grown fruit that bursts with flavor. Its natural sweetness and smooth texture remain a Southern classic.

4. Tropicana Original No Pulp

Tropicana Original No Pulp delivers a balanced orange flavor that has defined breakfast tables for years. Its blend of sweetness and acidity creates a well-rounded profile.

This isn’t overly complex—it’s simple, reliable, and refreshingly familiar. The pulp-free finish makes it perfect for those who appreciate a clear, consistent taste.

5. Uncle Matt’s Organic Orange Juice

Uncle Matt’s Organic Orange Juice stands out as a natural, organic option with a subtle tang. Its pure, unmodified flavor captures the essence of sun-ripened oranges.

While its taste is refreshing, the organic certification comes at a premium. Still, it offers a clean, natural alternative for the eco-conscious consumer.

6. Lakewood Organic Pure Orange Juice

Lakewood Organic Pure Orange Juice boasts an intense, authentic flavor that true purists crave. With no preservatives or additives, every sip is as fresh as the day the oranges were harvested.

Its rich taste comes with a slightly higher price tag, but quality shines through. This juice is a testament to what pure, organic fruit can deliver.

7. Whole Foods 365 Orange Juice

Whole Foods 365 Orange Juice brings a crisp, clean taste that feels both modern and wholesome. Its flavor is fresh and inviting, yet the texture is a bit thinner than some competitors.

This option appeals to those who value simplicity and minimal processing. A solid choice when you need something quick and reliable without the extra frills.

8. Trader Joe’s Cold Pressed Orange Juice

Trader Joe’s Cold Pressed Orange Juice offers a refreshing burst with a hint of rustic charm. The cold pressing method preserves more natural flavors and nutrients.

However, it sometimes lacks the bold punch found in the top-tier brands. Still, it’s a budget-friendly option that delivers an authentically fresh experience.

9. Bolthouse Farms Orange Juice

Bolthouse Farms Orange Juice is undeniably sweet and smooth, capturing a lighter taste that some find a tad sugary. Its bright, almost candy-like flavor appeals to sweet-tooths.

Yet, that sweetness can overshadow the true essence of orange. It’s a refreshing choice, but it may not satisfy those seeking a more balanced, tangy profile.

10. Minute Maid Original

Minute Maid Original remains a reliable, everyday choice despite being made from concentrate. Its flavor is familiar, a go-to option for many households.

However, the conversion process sometimes strips away the natural brightness of fresh oranges. It’s convenient, but it lacks the depth of flavor found in more premium options.

11. Kirkland Signature Orange Juice

Kirkland Signature Orange Juice offers decent taste for its bulk pricing. The flavor is acceptable, yet it doesn’t quite hit the mark of quality or freshness.

Its consistency is serviceable, making it a practical choice for families on a budget. Still, it may leave discerning palates wanting more authenticity.

12. Naked Orange Juice

Naked Orange Juice is a thick, pulpy version that appeals to those who love texture. The robust pulp adds a layer of complexity and a hearty mouthfeel.

However, some might find the flavor slightly too processed, with a hint of over-sweetness. It’s a divisive option, appreciated by some and bypassed by others.

13. Great Value Orange Juice

Great Value Orange Juice disappoints with a flat, artificial taste that lacks the vibrancy of real fruit. The flavor is muted, and the consistency is watery compared to higher-quality brands.

It seems more about volume than quality, leaving little room for genuine orange flavor. This one is best avoided if you’re after a fresh, punchy citrus experience.

14. Tropicana Twister

Tropicana Twister takes a detour from authenticity by packing in more sugar than real oranges deserve. The result is a drink that feels more like an overly sweet soda than fresh juice.

Its syrupy taste and heavy sweetness clash with the natural tang expected from quality fruit. If you’re chasing genuine flavor, this option falls short.

15. SunnyD

Once a childhood favorite, SunnyD now feels like a distant memory of artificially bright flavors. Its taste is a curious mix that hints more at processed orange concentrate than real fruit.

While it evokes nostalgia, its flavor profile doesn’t hold up to more natural alternatives. It’s a fun novelty but not the best choice for true orange juice enthusiasts.

16. Tang

Tang, an orange-flavored powder, completes the list with its unmistakable, nostalgic taste. Fun and fizzy, it never pretends to be real juice, but instead offers a playful, tangy experience.

Its bright, synthetic flavor is a blast from the past that sparks memories of retro breakfast drinks. Tang is an acquired taste—enjoy it if you’re in the mood for a quirky, bold flavor.